We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation. Learn more.

The 10 Best Flea and Tick Prevention Products, According To More Than 60 Dogs

Our favorite chewables, non-prescription topicals, and more

A dog sits behind the Simparica Trio Chews for Dogs box and pill

The Spruce Pets / Anna Mejorada

Flea and tick prevention products play an essential role in keeping a dog comfortable and healthy, and they also prevent the spread of flea and tick-borne illnesses.According to Dr. Gail Sommers Wolfe, D.V.M., untreated flea infestations can lead to health issues as serious as anemia or even death, while ticks “can transmit Lyme disease, Rocky Mountain Spotted Fever, Anaplasmosis, and Ehrlichiosis to humans.” 

A variety of preventative treatments can minimize these risks in advance of your dog’s contact with parasites, and they come in diverse forms, including pills, chews, ointments, and shampoos.

Since testing flea products would be tricky in our New York testing lab, we instead turned to our wide pool of volunteer testers, who have provided feedback on more than 700 pet products. After speaking with 69 different dog owners about how they handle at-home flea and tick prevention, we have recommendations backed by years of experiential data with dogs of all sizes, ages, and breeds.

Our favorite flea and tick preventative treatment is Simparica Trio Chews for Dogs. Each liver-flavored treat delivers a combination of three active ingredients—sarolaner, moxidectin, and pyrantel—which provide proven protection from fleas and ticks along with prevention of heartworm disease and intestinal parasites, like roundworms and hookworms.

What We Like
  • Protects against five types of ticks

  • Kills fleas at all life stages

  • FDA-approved for the prevention of Lyme disease

  • Prevents heartworm disease and intestinal worms

What We Don't Like
  • Does not protect against whipworms or tapeworms

Simparica Trio enables most dog parents to reduce the number of monthly preventatives they need to give to their dog down to one. It offers the same long-lasting, effective protection against ticks and fleas as Simparica, but also includes two additional active ingredients to prevent heartworm disease and intestinal worms.

Simparica Trio's combination of sarolaner, moxidectin, and pyrantel (the trio), work together to prevent heartworm, hookworm, and roundworm, protect against flea infestations, and guard against ticks, including five types commonly found in the United States: the Lone Star tick, Gulf Coast tick, American Dog tick, black-legged tick, and Brown Dog tick. The preventative is FDA-approved to block infections that may cause Lyme disease.

If you have a separate preventative for heartworm and intestinal parasites, or if you prefer to limit the amount of preventative medicine you give to your dog at one time, then standard Simparica is a reliable once-a-month liver-flavored chewable that provides protection from fleas and ticks in a single dose.

Simparica only contains one active ingredient, sarolaner, and is available in six different formulations depending on your dog’s weight. Standard Simparica is also more affordable than Trio, but we think the comprehensive heartworm and intestinal parasite coverage will be worth the extra price for most buyers, and is typically more affordable in combination than if you were to seek out a separate heartworm treatment.

Each once-a-month Simparica Trio chewable is liver flavored and easy to break up into smaller pieces if that makes it easier for you to give to your dog. Within hours of ingestion, Simparica Trio starts protecting your dog against parasites and diseases, and has been proven to maintain its potency beyond a 30-day window.

Simparica Trio requires a prescription from a veterinarian and is available in six sizes according to weight. It's safe for puppies as young as eight weeks old and weighing at least 2.8 pounds.

Prescription Required: Yes | Delivery Method: Chewable | Active Ingredients: Sarolaner, moxidectin, and pyrante | Effective Against: Fleas, ticks, heart worm, roundworms, and hookworms

What We Like
  • Protects against three species of hookworm and two species of roundworm

  • Prevents heartworm disease

  • Kills fleas at all life stages and protects against four species of ticks

What We Don't Like
  • No suitable for very small dogs (under eight pounds)

NexGard PLUS is a monthly chewable available only with a prescription that protects against fleas and ticks, prevents heartworm disease, and controls roundworms and hookworm. It has three active ingredients—afoxolaner, moxidectin, and pyrantel—the same as our pick for best overall, Simparica Trio, but there are a few key differences that might make one more advantageous than the other.

Each beef flavored NextGard PLUS chew (Simparica Trio is pork flavored) offers protection against three species of hookworms (Simparica Trio protects against two), two species of roundworms, four species of ticks (black-legged ticks, brown dog ticks, American dog ticks, and lone star tick), and fleas at all life stages.

For dogs, NexGard Plus is offered in four sizes based on weight, 8.1-17 pounds, 17.1-33 pounds, 33.1-66 pounds, and 66.1-132 pounds. It's approved for puppies as young as eight weeks old, but only if they weigh at least four pounds. For small dogs and puppies, Simparica Trio is approved for dogs weighing as little as 2.8 pounds.

Prescription Required: Yes | Delivery Method: Chewable | Active Ingredients: Afoxolaner, moxidectin, and pyrantel | Effective Against: Fleas and ticks

What We Like
  • Effective two hours after ingestion

  • Up to 12 weeks of flea and tick prevention

  • Flavored chewable resembles a treat

What We Don't Like
  • Doesn't kill parasites like ticks on contact, but does after they bite

Bravecto is a chewable preventative given to a dog like a treat and it's flavored to make it more appealing. Each prescription-only chew gets started killing fleas two hours after ingestion and provides up to 12 weeks of protection against fleas and ticks. That's three months of coverage in one chew. This makes Bravecto one of the most economical options for flea and tick prevention all summer long.

It's effective against parasites commonly found in the United States, including black-legged ticks, American dog ticks, brown dog ticks, and Lone Star ticks. But if Lone Star ticks are a concern where you live, you should consider giving your dog a Bravecto chew every eight weeks to keep your dog protected against the aggressive ticks.

If your dog has a thick or long coat (like Collies and Shih Tzus), you might find a topical preventative is difficult to apply correctly to your dog's skin, but the chew doesn't kill parasites on contact. Your dog might be bitten while taking Bravecto but the irksome pest will soon die which is helpful but still a risk. If Lyme disease from ticks is prevalent in your area, you should talk to your vet about having your dog vaccinated.

Prescription Required: Yes | Delivery Method: Chewable | Active Ingredient: Fluralaner | Effective Against: Fleas and ticks

What We Like
  • No prescription needed

  • Waterproof after 24 hours (although some sources recommend waiting 48 hours)

  • Kills fleas at all life stages

  • Available in three, six, eight, and twelve-count boxes

What We Don't Like
  • Leaves greasy spot on your dog’s skin

  • Not safe for use with cats

When it comes to warding off fleas and ticks, we recommend consulting with your veterinarian and seeking a prescription treatment. “Products prescribed by veterinarians are the best to use [for flea and tick prevention],” Dr. Wolfe told The Spruce Pets. “Veterinarians can advise which product would be best for your pet and how to use it properly.”

However, if you’re looking for a non-prescription solution, your best option is Frontline Plus. It’s a little more of a hassle to apply than a simple chewable, but it’s an well-tested, effective, and frequently veterinarian-recommended solution for killing ticks and fleas.

The active ingredients in this topical flea and tick treatment is fipronil, which kills adult fleas and ticks, and (S)-methoprene to kill flea eggs and larvae. By disrupting the flea life cycle at multiple stages Frontline can help reduce local infestations, preventing your dog from picking up fleas over and over. It’s also effective for chewing lice and sarcoptic mites. 

To apply Frontline, you snap open a little tube, then squeeze out the contents onto a patch of skin between your dog’s shoulder blades—a spot where they’re not able to lick. The formula is absorbed through the oil glands and provides a full month of protection. Be sure to keep your dog dry for at least 24 hours after application to ensure the product has soaked in. After that, it’s safe for your dog to go swimming or be around other pets and children.

Prescription Required: No | Delivery Method: Topical | Active Ingredients: Fipronil and (S)-methropene | Effective Against: Fleas in all stages, ticks, chewing lice, and sarcoptic mites

Another Great Non-Prescription Topical

Vectra 3D Spot Treatment

Vectra 3D for Dogs And Puppies
PHOTO:

Amazon

What We Like
  • Repels and kills fleas, ticks and mosquitoes

  • Available without a prescription

  • Fragrance free, non-greasy, and waterproof after 24 hours


What We Don't Like
  • Does not offer protection from mange mites

Our a dog who had previously experienced a flea outbreak while taking a different preventative, the switch to Vectra 3D quickly proved to be reliable and completely effective.

Vectra 3D is a topical solution with three active ingredients—dinitefuran, pyriproxyfen, and permethrin—that is available without a prescription. Each monthly treatment comes in a tube for application at the base of the neck, and provides protection from fleas, ticks, mosquitoes, lice, mites, biting flies, and sand flies—repelling and killing before the insects bite or sting your dog. Vectra 3D is easy to administer, but we recommend applying to your dog after they've had the chance to expend energy so they are more likely to sit still.

After 24 hours, the fragrance free, non-greasy solution is waterproof so it's a solid choice for dogs that love spending time outdoors. Vectra 3D comes in five sizes that correspond with a dog's weight, from five to over 95 pounds. It's also suitable for use on puppies as young as eight weeks.

Prescription Required: No | Delivery Method: Topical | Active Ingredients: Dinitefuran, pyriproxyfen, and permethrin | Effective Against: Fleas, ticks, mosquitoes, lice, mites, biting flies, and sand flies

What We Like
  • Easy to administer beef flavored chew

  • Effective against fleas and ticks

  • Safe for puppies as young as eight weeks and as small as four pounds

What We Don't Like
  • Has not been well-researched for use with pregnant dogs

NexGard Soft Chew for Dogs can be given to puppies as young as eight weeks, as long as they weigh at least four pounds. The beef-flavored monthly chewables are highly effective for prevention of fleas and ticks. And unlike with some topical treatments, it’s okay if your dog gets wet immediately after ingesting a chew.

NexGard is FDA-approved and effective in preventing infections that cause Lyme disease. Afoxolaner, NexGard's main ingredient, is absorbed into the bloodstream after ingestion to kill fleas before they have a chance to lay eggs, and ticks, including the Lone Star, black-legged, American dog and brown dog varieties. 

NexGard is available in four sizes and you should select weight range that best aligns with your dog.

While NexGard is safe for use with most dogs, potential side effects to watch for include vomiting, diarrhea, lethargy, loss of appetite, and itching. Its use for pregnant dogs has also not been studied, which is also true of other drugs in this class, like the sarolaner in Simparica and Simparica Trio.

Prescription Required: Yes | Delivery Method: Chewable | Active Ingredients: Afoxolaner | Effective Against: Fleas and ticks

What We Like
  • Kills adult fleas, eggs and larvae, as well as ticks and lice on contact

  • Leaves coat soft and shiny

  • Known for its clean, fresh scent

What We Don't Like
  • May not prevent re-infestations as well as advertised

  • May not be safe for use with cats

Adams Plus Flea & Tick Shampoo combines the active flea and tick-killing ingredients pyrethrin, s-methropene, and butoxide with itch and skin-soothing ingredients like aloe, oatmeal, lanolin and coconut extract for a creamy, lightly-scented formula.

Great for sensitive-skinned pups, Adams Plus and can be used as-is or diluted with 2 parts water if needed to create a better lather.  A little goes a long way, too— instructions say that 1⅓ tablespoons is all you need per five pounds of pet weight. 

Available in 12-ounce, 24-ounce, or gallon-size containers, this shampoo is safe for dogs and puppies of 12 weeks and older—but you’ll want to be careful not to apply near the eyes. 

While effective at killing fleas, we’re less convinced of its preventative effectiveness. Adams Plus contains an insect growth regulator that the manufacturer claims can prevent flea development for up to 28 days. However, Dr. Melissa Hall, Dutch vet specialist and board certified veterinary dermatologist advised that the shampoo is better used in conjunction with other preventative treatments, telling The Spruce Pets that it’s "good for a current infestation but will not be an effective preventative."

While Adams Plus Flea & Tick Shampoo is generally considered safe for use with cats, we recommend against it, since cats are sensitive to the active ingredient pyrethrin.

Prescription Required: No | Delivery Method: Topical | Active Ingredients: Pyrethrins, s-methropene, and piperonyl butoxide | Effective Against: Fleas at all stages, ticks, and lice | Size: 12 ounce bottle

What We Like
  • Creates a barrier against fleas, ticks, roaches, and other pests

  • Organic and food grade quality

  • Can be used indoors or outdoors

  • Free of harmful chemicals

  • Comes with a powder duster

  • Available at a wide range of retailers

What We Don't Like
  • Effectiveness is decreased when wet

Diatomaceous earth is a powdered sedimentary rock containing the fossilized remains of microalgae known as diatoms. Because it is mildly abrasive and highly absorbent, this powder has several practical applications, including as an insecticide. Diatomaceous earth kills fleas, ticks, bedbugs, cockroaches, and other pests by disrupting the waxy outer layer of their exoskeletons and dehydrating them.The powder can be spread anywhere to form an anti-parasite border, plus it is harmless to humans and pets.

We prefer Harris Diatomaceous Earth because it contains zero additives, is registered with the Organic Minerals Research Institute (OMRI), and is both mined and packaged in the United States. It also comes with a powder duster in the bag, which lets you spray powder into the crevices alongside refrigerators and other hard-to-reach places.

You can spread this diatomaceous earth practically anywhere, such as by dusting carpets, surrounding the legs of furniture, placing in corners, or spreading in your yard and garden. It’s best to target problem areas, since the light powder needs to be reapplied occasionally.

Harris Diatomaceous Earth is available in a four pound bag, and 10-percent of profits are donated to the Etowah Valley Humane Society in Georgia.

Prescription Required: No | Delivery Method: Powder | Active Ingredients: Organic, food grade diatomaceous earth | Effective Against: Fleas in all life stages, ticks, cockroaches, bedbugs, carpet beetles, spiders, ants, centipedes, and more

What We Like
  • Suitable for dogs as young as six weeks

  • Kills fleas and prevents eggs from hatching

  • Prevents heartworm disease

  • Treatment and control of ear mites, sarcoptic mange, and ticks

What We Don't Like
  • Additional tick preventative might be needed

Heartworm disease is transmitted between animals by mosquitos who carry the larva that infiltrates the bloodstream, so it's important to have your dog tested annually by your veterinarian. You can also help prevent heartworm disease by giving your dog a monthly preventative that repels mosquitos. Revolution Topical Solution for Dogs requires a prescription from a veterinarian, but each monthly dose of the easy-to-apply topical solution offers reliable defense against heartworm disease along with protection from fleas, ticks, sarcoptic mange, and ear mites.

Revolution for Dogs has one active ingredient, selmectin, which is used to fight parasites. If your dog has an active infestation of ear mites, ticks or sarcoptic mange, Revolution will also help you control the situation and prevent further infection. But if you live in an area where ticks are a concern, you may find that you'll need to pair Revolution with another preventative. You should consult with your veterinarian, but many dog parents give their dog NexGard along with Revolution, which adds the active ingredient, afoxolaner, to prevent Lyme disease.

When purchasing Revolution, select the weight range that best aligns with your dog's current size. For puppies (and also kittens!) weighing five pounds or less, the color of the Revolution box is mauve instead of red and the formula is gentle enough for use on young furry friends.

Prescription Required: Yes | Delivery Method: Topical | Active Ingredients: Selamectin | Effective Against: Heartworm disease, fleas of all life stages, ticks, lice, ear mites, and sarcoptic mange

What We Like
  • Effective against fleas, ticks, and mosquitos

  • Natural citrus scent

  • Works on puppies as young as 12 weeks

  • Cruelty-free

What We Don't Like
  • Must be used frequently

  • Can cause eye irritation; must be careful to avoid eyes, nose and mouth when bathing

Repel fleas and ticks naturally with your dog’s bath when you suds them up with this product. An excellent choice for sensitive-skinned dogs, Tropiclean Natural Flea and Tick shampoo is equipped with several natural EPA-approved flea, tick, and mosquito repellents, including lemongrass oil, clove oil, cedarwood oil, cinnamon oil, and moisturizing sesame oil. Not only does it work to help kill parasites (adults as well as larvae and eggs) on contact, the Maximum Strength variety also smells fresh and citrus-y for up to a week after use. 

An added benefit is its soap-free quality, using a coconut cleanser to get your pup clean without rinsing away any topical treatments you may have applied prior to bathtime. It also comes in spill-resistant packaging so you won’t waste any if it tips over. Available in 20-ounce or gallon-size shampoo bottles, as well as a spot treatment, collars, home, bedding, and yard sprays, you can choose to add what works best for your household. 

Prescription Required: No | Delivery Method: Topical (shampoo) | Active Ingredients: Lemongrass oil, cedarwood oil, cinnamon oil, clove oil and sesame oil | Effective Against: Fleas, ticks, and mosquitos 

Final Verdict

Our favorite preventative is Simparica Trio Chews for Dogs which contains three active ingredients to safely and effectively kill and prevent fleas, ticks while protecting against heartworm disease, hookworms, and roundworms. If you prefer a topical treatment, Vectra 3D Flea & Tick Spot Treatment for Dogs, is a reliable choice that doesn't require a prescription and is waterproof 24 hours after application.

Warning

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency is currently evaluating the safety of Seresto Flea & Tick Prevention Collars in light of a wave of consumer complaints. While the EPA has yet to find a link between the chemicals in flea collars and pet deaths, the volume of reported incidents related to Seresto have led to Congressional investigations, a ban in Canada, and a class-action lawsuit settled for $15 million. We no longer recommend Seresto flea collars. The EPA is also considering safety issues related to a number of other flea collar brands, and so we do not currently recommend flea collars.

What to Look for in a Flea and Tick Prevention Product

Delivery Method

There are several types of flea and tick prevention products that are popular today, including topicals, oral tablets, shampoos, sprays, and collars. Topical formulas are liquids that are either sprayed on the skin and fur or applied to the back of your dog's neck, while oral tablets are designed to be eaten—oral medications are preferable if your dog frequently gets wet, which can wash off topical treatments, but they're often more expensive than topicals. Shampoos often need to be reapplied several times per month. Wipes and collars may also be used, while some treatments may be applied to the ground outside or to floors and bedding inside.

Active Ingredients

Most flea and tick prevention products contain some type of insecticide that targets either the living flea or its eggs. It's best to talk to your veterinarian to figure out which ingredients will work best for your dog.

Some commonly used ingredients that kill fleas and ticks include:

  • Fipronil: Found in products like Frontline and PetArmor, this chemical kills on contact by disrupting the insect’s central nervous system.
  • S-methoprene: Sometimes referred to by a trade name, Precor, this chemical is an insect growth regulator which disrupts the hormone levels of insects rather than killing them.
  • Afoxolaner: This chemical induces the death of parasites after brief exposure. Causes hyperexcitation by attacking the insect’s central nervous system. Fond in NexGard.
  • Sarolaner: Found in products like Simparica Trio, this chemical works after ingestion and inhibits certain neurotransmitters and other receptors. Research indicates that it’s safe and more effective than similar ingredients.
  • Selamectin: Found in products like Selarid, in parasites this chemical causes overexcitement of the nervous system leading to paralysis and death, but it's remarkably safe for dogs, with minimal side effects.
  • Permethrin: Contained in products like K-9 Advantix and Bio Spot On, this causes spasms, paralysis and death by disrupting the nervous system of parasites.
  • Lotilaner: Found in products like Credelio, this chemical kills parasites by impacting the nervous system after being ingested.
  • Flumethrin: Found in products like Seresto flea collars, this chemical disrupts the transmission of nervous impulses in parasites.
  • Deltamethrin: Found in products such as Frontline, this works after contact or ingestion by interrupting the central nervous system.
  • Fluralaner: Found in products like Bravecto, this chemical targets the nervous system and kills fleas before they can lay eggs.

Longevity/Frequency of Use

Different flea and tick products are effective for different lengths of time. Some need to be reapplied every week or more, while others might a month or longer. Not only will this affect how often you need to re-administer the treatment, but it will also dictate how much you'll spend on flea and tick treatments each year.

The efficacy of flea and tick preventative products can depend on several factors, including the drug's "half-life," which is a measure of how long it takes before the amount of a specific drug in your dog's blood system drops to half its initial load. However, doses are often designed to compensate, so even if a drug's half-life is two weeks, it's likely designed to still be an effective dose beyond that point.

Certain products are also susceptible to wear, such as topical treatments that adhere to your dog's skin, but may slowly rinse away during bathing or swimming.

FAQ
  • How can you tell if your dog has fleas?

    There are several telltale signs that your dog might have fleas. If you notice that your dog is itching more than usual, particularly at its flank or above its tail, you'll want to check to see if you can spot any of these little bugs in its coat. If you part your pet's fur, you'll often be able to see "flea dirt," which looks like tiny black specks, or even black bugs that may jump away.

  • How can you prevent your dog from getting fleas?

    In addition to using a flea and tick prevention product on your dog, there are a few ways you can reduce their risk of getting fleas. Fleas prefer to live in shaded outdoor areas with sand, leaves, or other debris, so you can help prevent fleas by keeping your grass cut short and keeping your dog from playing in areas where fleas might be hiding. You can also treat your home and yard with food grade diatomaceous earth, which helps to kill adult fleas and ticks.

  • Can most flea treatments be used on puppies?

    In general, puppies should only be given flea treatments after they're weaned—typically around seven or eight weeks of age. It's important to check the age range on the flea treatment you're using to see if it's safe to use on your puppy. Your vet will also be able to recommend an appropriate treatment for your young dog.

    "The pet’s size is important to consider. For instance, for our itty-bitty dogs (like teacup Chihuahuas or Yorkies) a smaller size option is necessary and for giant breed dogs, we may need to give two different sizes to make sure we are getting to a therapeutic dosage," Dr. Hall says.

    She adds that veterinary guidance can be crucial in the safe administration of these products because, without it, “they can cause irritation to the skin and eyes, and when used injudiciously, they can also cause infertility.”

Why Trust The Spruce Pets?

This article was researched and written by KJ Callihan, a writer for The Spruce, who has worked in animal shelters, helped socialize animals for adoption, and fostered animals of various kinds. She also writes for CNET, AAA Northeast magazine, and more.

This roundup was written in consultation with experts, including Dr. Gail Sommers Wolfe, D.V.M., of her own private practice: Bennett Road Animal Clinic in Okemos, Michigan. We also spoke with Dr. Melissa Hall, a Dutch vet specialist and board certified veterinary dermatologist. In addition, we followed guidance provided by the FDA.

A survey of our existing pool of dog testers was also taken, with detailed feedback provided by 69 dog owners. Each respondent provided comprehensive data on their dog's age, size, and breed, in addition to their detailed history with flea and tick prevention products.

An older version of this article was written by Anne Fritz, a freelance lifestyle writer with over 20 years of experience.

The Spruce Pets uses only high-quality sources, including peer-reviewed studies, to support the facts within our articles. Read our editorial process to learn more about how we fact-check and keep our content accurate, reliable, and trustworthy.
    1. "Lyme Disease in Dogs." Merck Veterinary Manual.
  1. "Pyrethrin/Pyrethroid Poisoning in Cats." VCA Animal Hospitals.

  2. Faulde, M. K.; Tisch, M.; Scharninghausen, J. J. (August 2006). "Efficacy of modified diatomaceous earth on different cockroach species (Orthoptera, Blattellidae) and silverfish (Thysanura, Lepismatidae)". Journal of Pest Science. doi:10.1007/s10340-006-0127-8

Advertisement